Why is shortcrust pastry used for the base of a meat pie instead of puff pastry?
Rachel Fowler
Updated on March 12, 2026
Why is shortcrust pastry used for the base of a meat pie instead of puff pastry?
Using shortcrust pastry for the base makes it easier to handle, especially when eating individual pies. A base isn’t necessary for a large pie, but will add a good ratio of pastry to filling. The top, meanwhile, is made from buttery puff pastry, which is light and crisp, and will rise in the oven.
What is pate Sucree pastry and how it differs to shortcrust pastry?
Pâte Sucrée – Is the one we are learning today and the sweet version of these pastries. It contains egg and more sugar than the standard shortcrust pastry. Pâte Brisée – Is your standard savory tart crust. Similar to American pie crust but stronger, not as flaky and with a finer crumb.
Should you add egg to shortcrust pastry?
The choice varies depending on the desired crumbliness: the yolks – being fatter – will accentuate it, while the egg whites are for a crispier shortcrust pastry. More generally, to make a soft shortcrust pastry for tarts it is always better to use whole eggs.
Can I use shortcrust pastry instead of puff pastry?
Puff pastry can generally be described as flaky, light and buttery, good for pies and pastries, while shortcrust pastry has a more crumbly, biscuit-like texture which is good for tart or quiche cases. When making a pie, many cooks use shortcrust on the bottom and puff pastry for the lid.
Is shortcrust pastry same as pie crust?
Shortcrust pastry is the same thing as pie dough. Shortcrust pastry is the same thing as tart dough. If you can make a great shortcrust pastry, you can make incredible pies (like this one – but use this crust recipe instead) and tarts.
What is shortcrust pastry called in the US?
pie dough
Shortcrust is popular all over the world for both sweet and savory pies. In the United States, however, it is usually called “pie dough” or some similar name.
Is Pate Brisee the same as shortcrust pastry?
Pâte Brisée is very similar to shortcrust pastry, with a 1/2 fat to flour ratio and the ability to be used for sweet and savoury recipes.
What is the flour to fat ratio for shortcrust pastry?
4-to-1
Shortcrust pastry dough is a simple recipe used for pies, tarts, and quiche. It calls for just four ingredients—flour, fat, salt, and water—and the ratio of flour to fat is usually 4-to-1. Shortcrust pastry is easy to make and can be prepared either by hand or with a food processor.
Why does my shortcrust pastry crack when rolling?
It sounds like it was too cold to roll. The butter solidifies and the dough will break up when it’s rolled. If it’s had longer than 30 minutes in the fridge, take it out and leave it in its bag for about 20 minutes. When you unwrap the dough give it a little press with your fingers.
What are the two methods used to make shortcrust pastry?
Mixing Methods for Shortcrust Pastry
- Classic Method.
- Creaming Method (Sablée)
- Whipped Method.
How long does it take to make shortcrust pastry?
With a food processor, the dough is done in 1 minute. I exaggerate not. This is a shortcrust pastry recipe that is perfect to use for sweet and savoury pies and tarts. There’s no magic ingredient in this pie crust recipe, it has the same ingredients as 99% of other recipes out there.
Is this savoury tart crust recipe the most used in your kitchen?
This Savoury Tart Crust recipe is probably one of the most used recipe in my kitchen, ever! I LOVE making and eating tarts and they are most often sweet ones with a Sweet Shortcrust Pastry, Pâte Sablée or a Chocolate Pie Crust. But when it comes to main meals, I equally love making Quiches and Savoury Tarts that require a different type of pastry.
How do you bake pastry in a tart Pan?
Photo 11: Remove the baking paper sheets and transfer the pastry over your Tart Pan. Gently slide the pastry along the sides of the pan to create a 90′ angle with the bottom. Press it against the edges of the pan so it sticks to it, then use a small pairing knife or a rolling pin to cut off any excess.
What do you use to make pie crust dough?
Flour, salt and if making pastry for a sweet filling, sugar. I feel like I’ve paid my dues over the years, making pie crust dough by hand – either rubbing the butter in with the tips of fingers or using a pastry cutter. Nowadays, I opt for the simple, foolproof, 1 minute method using a food processor.